Protests erupt over harbor relocation plan in ‘usually quiet’ S.F. neighborhood

by Sam Whiting : sfchronicle – excerpt

A summer of simmering San Francisco neighborhood resistance to a plan to build a new small boat harbor in front of the Marina Green boiled over into a protest outside a community meeting on Wednesday.

Members of the recently organized citizen group Keep the Waterfront Open gathered outside the meeting hosted by the San Francisco Recreation and Park Department at Moscone Rec Center.

The plan was to carry signs, march and chant at the entrance to the meeting in the old gymnasium on Chestnut Street. Around 75-100 energized people showed up, some with signs in hand — though they forwent the march, and the chanting was done mainly by two 8-year-old girls, Siobhan Butler and Carolyn Wong, president and vice president of the Earth Club at their school.

“Save the cove!” they chanted loudly, alternating with, “Clean the cove!”…

Some of the more adamant protesters are still fighting a $190 million settlement reached in 2021 between the city attorney and PG&E to pay for the cleanup. Homeowners along Marina Boulevard claim that the cleanup plan is insufficient for remediating both the boat harbor and the property beneath their homes…(more)

Historic San Francisco Theater Developer in Feud With City That Could Kill 74 Homes Plan

by Garrett Leahy :sfstandard – excerpt

A feud between a property developer and a city official may squash housing plans for a dilapidated old San Francisco movie theater.

The conflict centers on a local supervisor’s plan to designate the Alexandria Theater as a historic landmark, which the property owner says will cause development costs to skyrocket, making it impossible to complete the project—and leaving the theater in its blighted condition.

Development plans for the theater have fallen through before. Now the city and restoration advocates are seething at the thought of the failure of another project that could transform the theater into much-needed San Francisco housing if completed…

Woody LaBounty, head of San Francisco Heritage, a nonprofit that seeks to preserve San Francisco’s unique architecture, said his organization has pushed for the theater’s redevelopment for at least 15 years. The local historian said he’s tired of seeing the Alexandria Theater in a state of disrepair and wants to see it redeveloped.

“The whole idea was housing in the back, and swim center in the front,” LaBounty said. “At what point are we supposed to believe that the owners don’t have the money to build it because it’s a historic landmark? The owners have had two approved projects, and they haven’t done anything.”…(more)

Developers of controversial 50-story tower in Sunset District sue S.F.

By Megan Fan Munce : sfchronicle – excerpt

The developers behind a controversial project to build a 50-story condo building in San Francisco’s Sunset District have sued the city, claiming that officials misinterpreted and violated a state law meant to incentivize affordable housing.

California’s Density Bonus Law (DBL) is designed to incentivize the construction of low to moderate income housing by allowing developers to build more housing units in a project than local regulations normally allow if they agree to make a larger percentage of those units affordable housing.

In a lawsuit filed Tuesday in the San Francisco Superior Court, the developers, 2700 Sloat Holding, which owns the site, argues that the city is misinterpreting the requirements of the law and also violating it by requiring developers to pay certain fees…

San Francisco Planning Director Rich Hillis said he had not reviewed the exact details of the complaint, but said he believes the developers of the project have misinterpreted how far beyond local regulation the density bonus law allows developers to build.

“It kind of defies logic that you could take a site that has a 100-foot height limit, apply a 50% bonus to it and somehow get a 560-foot tower,” Hilles said. “We think they’re wrong in their interpretation of what’s allowed under the zoning.”…(more)

Farmers’ market drama is the last thing San Francisco needs right now

By Soleil Ho : sfchronicle – excerpt

On Monday, San Francisco’s Recreation and Parks Department held an open house at Civic Center focused on the city’s plan to revamp the area — a plan that includes the controversial decision to relocate a popular biweekly U.N. Plaza farmers’ market to nearby Fulton Plaza.

About 100 attendees looked at posters depicting stock photos of people doing Zumba in front of City Hall while casually pecking at catered snacks. The hollow plinking of a pingpong ball in play echoed through the room, but the mood was far from leisurely…

Is this what passes for “community engagement” in San Francisco? The big decisions have already been made — and according to advocates, no one knew about the changes to the market until it was too late…

“For them to claim that we’ve been working with them all along? That hasn’t happened,” he said.

Pulliam said it was only after he brought the rumors up to the Civic Center Community Benefit District that the city arranged a meeting with him to share its plan, which he objected to immediately. His suggestion that the market share the plaza with the skate park went unheeded. Since then, city departments haven’t shared any updated maps of the space with him; he had to ask me what they were planning.

The worst part? This quickie play at urban renewal is all just an experiment. If the revamp doesn’t hash out within six months, Pulliam said he was told the farmers’ market can go right back to where it’s been for the past 40 years.

All of this chaos, and all of the people that will have to scramble because of it, is just spaghetti being thrown at the wall by a city that doesn’t seem to give a damn either way…(more)

I’ll bet everyone who ever held a job has experienced a manager who managed by creating chaos. That appears to be the primary goal of our current administration and they are really good at that job.

Unfortunately management by chaos never accomplishes much other than to convince people they don’t need that job. I remember a few times I was trapped and could not wait to leave so I could regain my sanity.

We understand that the city is understaffed and has a long process for hiring that usually takes at least 18 months. That 18 months figure comes up a lot in excuses for the slow process we see in filling empty affordable units and other city programs. How do we get past the 18 months slowdown and management by chaos? Hopefully we will soon have some options in new management styles before we kill off what is left of the “Heart of San Francisco”. The patient needs a transfusion fast. See https://hotcfarmersmarket.org/

‘It’s going to be a nightmare’: SF displaces farmers market to make room for skate area

By Timothy Karoff : sfgate – excerpt

A beloved farmers market’s tenure in U.N. Plaza is nearing an end.

City officials have elected to move the Heart of the City Farmers’ Market, a staple of Civic Center for 42 years, to the nearby Fulton Street parking lot, making room for a skate area, chess boards, pingpong tables and Teqball (a sport similar to table tennis) tables, according to a press release from the farmers market.

The market will move one street over to Fulton Street between Larkin and Hyde on Sept. 3, and construction of the recreation area is set to wrap up in November. The decision is an attempt at revitalization, with hopes that a vibrant hub of activity will make the area safer, as U.N. Plaza is known as a site for the sale and purchasing of drugs

“Nobody has a food access program as large as ours,” Steve Pulliam, the market’s executive director, told SFGATE. “Certainly not in California. We have the numbers to prove that.”

Pulliam cited a host of issues with the new location. Compared to the U.N. Plaza location, Fulton Street’s space is limited. He pointed out that in the new location, vendors won’t be able to park their vehicles behind their stalls, leaving them exposed to smashed windows and break-ins. This also puts merchandise at risk, since some vendors use their vehicles to store extra produce…(more)

Why not just have the market extended to more days of the week? Or do some activities that don’t disrupt it on the off-days. Does anyone really think this is going to stop the activities around the BART station?

These three new blocks of housing are among S.F.’s best. They’re for the formerly homeless

By John King : sfchronicle – excerpt

The need to build new housing in cities tends to be discussed in simplistic terms — for or against, tall or short, market rate or affordable.

Three recently completed complexes in San Francisco illuminate the core issue that too often gets lost: Such housing should be measured by its capacity to improve people’s lives.

The three buildings do this despite very different settings: Treasure Island, Mission Bay and near ever-troubled Sixth Street. They succeed by providing shelter and services for people who were living on city streets and by enhancing their neighborhoods.

They nurture community, inside and out.

“The idea is not just to house people, but for people to thrive,” said Vanna Whitney of Leddy Maytum Stacy, the architect for the four-story, 140-unit HomeRise at Mission Bay. “We want something that feels like a home and not an institution.”…

The same goal anchors Maceo May Apartments, 104 units of supportive housing on Treasure Island that opened officially in May. Architectural firm Mithun designed it for Swords to Plowshares, and all residents are military veterans who were living on the streets…

The largest and most ambitious of the three newcomers is at 1064 Mission St. between Sixth and Seventh streets, one of the most troubled stretches of San Francisco’s downtown area…

They’re islands of stability and economic diversity in a city where neither is abundant. They’re also models of thoughtful design at both the human and urban scale — a trait that should be encouraged, whoever the residents might be…(more)

Construction suspended on $1.2 billion tower — one of S.F.’s only big building projects

By J.K. Dineen : sfchronicle – excerpt

The developer of a $1.2 billion mixed-use project at the corner of Market Street and Van Ness Avenue has suspended construction, the latest blow in a cascade of bad news that has hit the greater Civic Center and Mid-Market neighborhoods in recent years.

Branded as Hayes Point, the 540-foot tower at 30 Van Ness Ave. had been a rare bright spot in a district that has lost high-profile office tenants like Uber, Reddit and Block, as well as the city’s largest Whole Foods, which shut down a year after opening.

Hayes Point was one of the few major construction projects underway in San Francisco at the moment.

City officials have been pushing legislation to revive downtown and Civic Center. Recent moves include cutting some fees and the amount of inclusionary housing in some market-rate projects with the hope of jump-starting construction. Legislation to smooth office-to-residential conversions is also moving ahead…

Hayes Point is a rarity in San Francisco because it is a true mixed-use project, with 333 for-sale condos on top of 290,000 square feet of office space, with arts space and retail on the ground floor.

In a statement, Lendlease Executive General Manager Arden Hearing said his group would be “pausing construction on Hayes Point until markets normalize and we’re able to bring in early tenancy commitments, or a capital partner, or both.”…(more)

RELATED:

S.F. must create 82,000 new homes in 8 years. The city is already behind

San Francisco Merchants Hold Small Business ‘Funeral’ To Protest Geary St. Transit Plan

By George Kelly : sfstandard – excerpt

Photo by zrants

The mourners gathered Monday morning outside the former Thom’s Natural Foods in San Francisco’s Richmond District, watching as four black-clad, white-gloved men chanted and carried a black-draped coffin down Geary Boulevard.

The casket was adorned with notes listing Thom’s and other dearly departed businesses: Mike’s Chinese Restaurant, Silver Cut Hair Salon, Safe Harbor CPA, M.V. Code coding school, La Vie Vietnamese Restaurant, Mr. B.’s Sewing Machines.

The pallbearers chanted, “Geary Boulevard needs some help! Mayor Breed, we need your help! Jeff Tumlin, stop working against us!

“We’re gathered in memory of our beloved small businesses on Geary Boulevard,” former San Francisco Supervisor Sandra Lee Fewer told the group as the procession came to a stop outside Thom’s between two chairs with signs for San Francisco Mayor London Breed and San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Director of Transit Jeffrey Tumlin. Neither official was present

“We know that many of them could not recover after Covid,” Fewer said of the closed shops. “We are also here to honor the existing small businesses that are trying to build up their business to pre-pandemic levels, and they are not there.”…

Supervisor Ahsha Safaí said Breed and others need to listen to the business owners.

“The mayor needs to listen. The mayor needs to be present. She needs to step up, and she needs to show leadership. That’s what being mayor means,” said Safai, who is challenging Breed in the 2024 election. “Not hiding behind decisions of five appointed commissioners that she controls, and the director that she controls. The power rests with the mayor in this decision. We need leadership in this city right now.”...(more)

Traffic puts eyes on the street. Removing traffic and parking killed the downtown and makes it feel empty and not safe.

 

Sunset tower isn’t out of scale — S.F.’s housing crisis is

By Joe DiMento : sfchronicle – excerpt

Much ink has been spilled in San Francisco about a proposed development at 2700 Sloat Blvd. that would create a 50-story condo in the Outer Sunset, a neighborhood with no buildings over six stories tall. The development likely received its death blow when the Board of Appeals voted down the appeal of the Planning Commission’s rejection of the project.

But even if the Sunset tower never becomes more than an artist’s rendering that proliferated across media outlets, it has already achieved something important — moved our “Housing Overton Window” closer to where it needs to be to alleviate our housing crisis.

In political science, the “Overton window” is the term for the spectrum of acceptable political beliefs in a given system. For decades, it has been perfectly acceptable for neighborhoods like the Outer Sunset to oppose nearly all new multiunit developments. This has created a catastrophic housing shortage to the tune of 3.5 million units statewide — manifesting in astronomical rents and home prices in California and fully one-half of the entire country’s unsheltered homeless population(more)